McGuinty eyes selling shares in LCBO, Hydro One
Saturday, March 6th, 2010
So that’s what McGuinty’s government is up to. Ten bucks says this idea is Goldman-Sachs’. The notion of a piecemeal selloff of public assets is good in theory, a way to climb down from state ownership of market sectors that have little to nothing to do with the protection of citizen rights. But in the current context, there are problems of application that arise. How much of a return will taxpayers realize on their cumulative investments? And in a market that has little to do with free and unrestricted trade between individuals, and everything to do with prefigured benefits for institutional investors what will be the end result? Will there be a new centralized ownership of these resources, and what might be the consequences to Ontario’s (energy) sovereignty – energy, in a centralized market, has already been realized as a strategic asset. And finally, will there be any control over levels of ownership in these assets in order to ease the transition to a privatized energy economy? (Yes, reading further into the details). But perhaps, ironically, rather than this fascistic or P3 – public/private partnership or ‘corporativist’ – model, a breaking of these nationalized trusts into separate departments and a sale of those interests to private partners (for a fair price) might be the best way to encourage true market innovation in an echo of the era of trust-breaking from the past century.
Flashback: Ontario in no rush to sell Crown assets, minister says | Ontario Premiere McGuinty heralds Samsung ‘green energy’ deal | Ont. deficit could linger for years: McGuinty | Ontario eyes sale of crown corporations | HST bill passes, 13% tax starts July 1 | Poll: HST equals Hated Sales Tax | Flaherty eyes sale of Canadian government assets | Cities Debate Giving Away Public Infrastructure to Bankers
Robert Benzie, The Toronto Star
March 6, 2010
![]() |
| Finance Minister Dwight Duncan hinted at the proposed sale. |
The Ontario government is looking at creating a publicly held $60 billion “super corporation” of assets such as the Liquor Control Board of Ontario and Hydro One and then selling a minority share to private investors, sources told the Star.
Insiders say that is an option under active consideration as part of Premier Dalton McGuinty’s ambitious five-year plan called Open Ontario, which will be spelled out in Monday’s Speech from the Throne.
While government sources insist nothing is set in stone, McGuinty is aggressively seeking ways to maximize the value of the province’s considerable holdings and at the same time jolt the economy.
A “super corporation” of the 610-store LCBO booze monopoly, the Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corp. gambling empire, and blue-chip utilities Ontario Power Generation and Hydro One, could be worth between $50 billion and $60 billion.
Unlike the failed scheme by the previous Progressive Conservative government to sell Hydro One in 2002, the Liberals would not have an outright sale of Crown holdings.
Nor would any deal be structured like the Tories’ controversial 1999 liquidation of Highway 407 for $3.1 billion, which has led to soaring tolls for drivers.
“You would put all the assets inside a shell and then issue shares on that shell. That way there’s still an element of public ownership,” a Liberal insider said Friday.


The former residents of a bulldozed black community and their descendants have received an official apology from the mayor of Halifax.
Since they were re-elected in October, 2008, the federal Conservatives have rolled out 3,229 press releases from government departments, agencies, and Crown corporations which announce funding commitments of various sizes for various regions. We maintain a database of information contained in those releases and here’s the latest tallies from that database. A chart summarizing the number of releases by the province in which the spending was announced and the total dollars committed in those releases is at the left. Here’s some of the trends:
U.S. President Barack Obama has unveiled a new compromise health-care plan that attempts to bridge the differences between the stalled House and Senate bills.
The world’s economic powers appear to be moving closer to a global bank tax in response to last year’s crisis, Gordon Brown suggested today.
Ontario’s controversial move to harmonize sales taxes will be part of a new $1.6-million government ad campaign that’s poised to hit newsstands on Thursday.
Federal court hearings continued Tuesday on a lawsuit that could transform biotechnology in the United States by eliminating gene patents.