Related: H1N1 still a pandemic: WHO chief | Low H1N1 vaccination rate alarms health experts | H1N1 pandemic call to be reviewed | EU Council Health Chair: Swine Flu Pandemic Was A Hoax | WHO to examine its H1N1 response | Flu Inc.: How vaccines became big business | Swine flu pandemic ‘less lethal than expected’ | Dr. Richard Schabas — How they larded H1N1 facts with fear | H1N1 overplayed by media, public health: MDs | Elite Council Recording Suggests Creating False Scarcity To Drive Up Demand For H1N1 Vaccine | WHO pandemic definition too broad, doctor contends | Flu Season Has Already Peaked in US, Little Benefit to H1N1 Jab: Study | GlaxoSmithKline profit rises on flu drug | UK: National Health Service frontline staff shun H1N1 vaccine | Swine flu death rate similar to seasonal flu: expert | Swine flu unlikely to become superbug | UK Government Swine Flu Advisor On Vaccine Maker Payroll | Swine flu: How scared should we be? | Top Epidemiologist Slams Swine Flu Fearmongering | Lessons of 1976: swine flu, fear, mass vaccinations, wasted millions
Randeep Ramesh, The Guardian
June 4, 2010
Scientists who drew up the key World Health Organisation guidelines advising governments to stockpile drugs in the event of a flu pandemic had previously been paid by drug companies which stood to profit, according to a report out today.
An investigation by the British Medical Journal and the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, the not-for-profit reporting unit, shows that WHO guidance issued in 2004 was authored by three scientists who had previously received payment for other work from Roche, which makes Tamiflu, and GlaxoSmithKline (GSK), manufacturer of Relenza.
City analysts say that pharmaceutical companies banked more than $7bn (Ãƒâ€šÃ‚Â£4.8bn) as governments stockpiled drugs. The issue of transparency has risen to the forefront of public health debate after dramatic predictions last year about a swine flu pandemic did not come true.
Some countries, notably Poland, declined to join the panic-buying of vaccines and antivirals triggered when the WHO declared the swine flu outbreak a pandemic a year ago this week. The UK, which warned that 65,000 could die as a result of the virus, spent an estimated Ãƒâ€šÃ‚Â£1bn stockpiling drugs and vaccines; officials are now attempting to unpick expensive drug contracts.
The cabinet office has launched an inquiry into the cost to the taxpayer of the panic-buying of drugs.
Today, the Council of Europe, produces a damning report into how a lack of openness around “decision making” has bedevilled planning for pandemics.
“The tentacles of drug company influence are in all levels in the decision-making process,” said Paul Flynn, the Labour MP who sits on the council’s health committee. “It must be right that the WHO is transparent because there has been distortion of priorities of public health services all over Europe, waste of huge sums of public money and provocation of unjustified fear.”
Although the experts consulted made no secret of industry ties in other settings, declaring them in research papers and at universities, the WHO itself did not publicly disclose any of these in its seminal 2004 guidance. In its note, the WHO advised: “Countries that are considering the use of antivirals as part of their pandemic response will need to stockpile in advance.”
Many nations would adopt this guidance, including Britain. In 2005, the government said it had begun bulk-buying the drug Tamiflu, initially ordering 14.6m doses after bird flu killed 40 in Asia.
The specific guidance on antivirals was written by Professor Fred Hayden. He has confirmed in an email that he was being paid by Roche for lectures and consultancy work at the time the guidance was produced and published. He received payments from GSK for consultancy and lecturing until 2002. He said “[declaration of interest] forms were filled out for the 2002 consultation”.
The previous year Hayden was also one of the main authors of a Roche-sponsored study that asserted what was to become a main Tamiflu selling point — its claim of a 60% reduction in flu hospitalisations.
Dr Arnold Monto was the author of the WHO annex dealing with vaccine usage in pandemics. Between 2000 and 2004, and at the time of writing the annex, Monto had openly declared consultancy fees and research support from Roche and GSK. No conflict of interest statement was included in the annex published by the WHO.
When asked if he had signed a declaration of interest form for WHO, Dr Monto said “conflict of interest forms are requested before participation in any WHO meeting”.
The third scientist, Professor Karl Nicholson, is credited with the WHO’s influential work Pandemic Influenza. According to declarations he made in the BMJ and Lancet in 2003, he had received sponsorship from GSK and Roche.
Even though the previous year these declarations had been openly made, no conflict of interest statement was included in the annex. Nicholson said he last had “financial relations” with Roche in 2001.
When asked if he had signed a declaration of interest form for WHO, he replied: “The WHO does require attendees of meetings, such as those held in 2002 and 2004, to complete declarations of interest.”
A WHO official told the BMJ it had to balance an individual’s privacy with the robustness of guidelines, which were subject to a wide external review process.
Source | See Also under Corruption: Clement blasted for G8 riding spending, Baird drags out 9/11 trope | Mulroney-Schreiber dealings inappropriate: report | Afghan president’s half-brother denies corruption | Lehman launches court battle against JPMorgan | MPs shouldn’t fear expenses audit: AG | Germany bans naked short-selling | Greece links U.S. banks to debt crisi | MPs reject request to audit expenses | Multiple Wall Street banks investigated over links to ratings agencies | SEC widens probe of Wall Street to include Morgan Stanley| RCMP launches investigation into five officers after in-custody death | Audit The Fed Push Strengthened By Second Front In Senate | Schreiber gets 8 years for tax evasion in Germany | Goldman execs squirm in face of angry U.S. Senators | Goldman’s Fabrice Tourre: Emails reveal he thought borrowers ‘won’t last long’ | In revealed e-mails, Goldman chief says we ‘made more than we lost’ by betting against market | Bombshell: Silverstein Wanted To Demolish Building 7 On 9/11 | German bank severs Goldman ties | George Galloway: leaked papers reveal Canada’s torment over banning MP | Goldman Sachs Eats Its Young | Afghan torture allegations erupt in UK | Goldman Sachs charged with $1bn fraud over toxic sub-prime securities | Quebec Liberals accused of judicial graft, Charest orders inquiry | Former Toronto drug squad officers must face trial after all, top court rules | White House approves assassination of cleric linked to Christmas bomb plot | GM dealers sue law firm for conflict — Cassels also had government contract during restructuring | US special forces ‘tried to cover-up’ botched Khataba raid in Afghanistan | Harkat defence gets bombshell help from declassified U.S. documents | Wall Street: Looting Main Street | Climategate Investigation A Monumental Whitewash | Afghan parliament says no to Karzai bid for more control over election watchdog | New chief Climategate investigator failed to declare eco directorship | Defence Department official used private contractors for spy network in AfPak | JPMorgan, Citigroup Helped Doom Lehman, Report Says | Ontario tax collectors get $45K severance, keep jobs in HST federalization deal | NDP accuses McGuinty of helping developers | Rights & Democracy dissidents fired | A perfect storm is brewing for the IPCC | UK: University at center of Climategate accused of misleading MPs, deleting information | Global warming panel to get independent review | Goldman role in Greek crisis probed | UK: Former Met police detective facing jail over cocaine smuggling plot | How EU Countries Cooked Books Using Derivatives | Hamid Karzai takes control of Afghanistan election watchdog | Nine Months Before Operation Northwoods, Government Leaders Suggested False Flag Terror in the Dominican Republic | N.Y.C.’s former top cop sentenced for felonies | Combine H1N1, seasonal flu vaccines: WHO | Goldman Sachs Helped Greece Obscure Debt Through Currency Swaps | MI5 chief denies cover-up claims over detainees | Climate emails review panellist quits after his impartiality questioned | Blackwater accused of defrauding US government, billing for hooker under ‘morale’ | Carbon trade phish scam disrupts exchanges | EU Council Health Chair: Swine Flu Pandemic Was A Hoax | Harper government violating Constitution: prof | Ont. top cop pushed for charges against protester | Leaked climate change emails scientist ‘hid’ data flaws | Blair defends decision to join U.S. in Iraq | Bloomberg: Secret Banking Cabal Emerges From AIG Shadows | Geithner Told To Quit After E Mails Reveal Involvement In AIG Cover-up | Canadian scientist says UN’s global warming panel ‘crossing the line’ | Manufactured ‘Science’: Another IPCC Scientist Reveals How UN Scientists talked about ‘trying to make IPCC report so dramatic that US would just have to sign Kyoto Protocol’ | Banks find gaping loophole in Obama financial reforms | The IPCC glacier meltdown: More global warming fraud exposed | Tories win ‘in-and-out’ ad spending case | Taxpayers’ millions paid to Indian institute run by UN IPCC climate chief | Wall Street’s leading bankers admit: we made mistakes | WHO to examine its H1N1 response | Explosive Leaked Emails Expose Treasury Secretary Geithner’s Deception in ‘Backdoor Bailout’ | American cash gives Yemen a reason to join the hunt for al-Qaeda | Tories force Elections Canada to accept campaign refund, hope to hit Liberals with bill | Group slams Chertoff on conflict of interest in scanner promotion | For more see The Memory Hole — Corruption