That right there, is what you might call a cynical destabilization campaign on the backs of the people who can least afford to be caught up in it. As this journal has been at some pains to point out in the past, ‘free trade’ does not involve reams of regulation, international courts, quasi-judicial processes, and intergovernmental panels. It involves – getting out of the way of the people that wish to trade. The same principle applies to questions of labour and immigration. Why are these natural movements saddled with restrictions? The answer is twofold – the artificial historic trade restrictions that have resulted in the buildup of wealth and economic privilege like a dam, denying economic flows to external states, and the historically recent phenomenon of welfare statism that buttresses internal support for the system. The suggestion, to simplify things, is that it’s like an irrigation project gone awry, where wealthy states have diverted flows leaving downstream communities parched, and building water levels up to a level that would be catastrophic were the dam to burst. So we can’t let the dam blow all at once, and since we’re a welfare state, if too many people are invited up to the public pool, we fear the amount of water in the public pool would fall below some threshold level. And, unfortunately, the distribution of water is controlled by central regulators on both sides of the dam, increasing the risk of corruption and scarcity. Neither the Canadian public nor the impoverished peoples downstream are to blame for this situation. So the question is – what is the best way to get out of corner we’ve painted ourselves into? Clearly the solution is not for agribusiness to refuse to pay Canadian labourers a living wage since it’s more convenient to import workers from afar and keep them under conditions that veer dangerously close to indentured servitude. The root of the problem is the international monetary system and its destruction of the middle class’s purchasing power. Fix that, root out corruption, extend natural human rights to all nationals, disassemble barriers to innovation, and then perhaps again we might have a nation able to welcome people that wish to build better lives for their families with more than the promise of a state handout or a slave-wage job where your employer holds your healthcard and the power to invite you back based on whether you know your place and are willing to work 72 hour weeks.
Flashback: UK: Pilot project for DNA, isotope analysis of immigrants ‘deeply flawed’ | Who counts as ‘human’?
Sandro Contenta, Laurie Monsebraaten, Toronto Star
November 1, 2009
Controversial federal program brings in foreigners for temporary jobs, but leaves them ripe for abuse
Foreigners in Canada on temporary work permits are being pushed into Toronto’s underground economy by the recession and a controversial federal program that leaves them vulnerable to abuse, a Star investigation has found.
They include people like Tony, a 29-year-old Honduran, who left his Alberta farm job after complaining of long hours and lower-than-promised wages. He rode a bus to Toronto in mid-September with two fellow Hondurans from the same farm. He now works illegally renovating homes, and his friends work illegally cleaning schools.
“I want to be someone, to do something with my life – that’s why I’m here,” says Tony, who fears being deported.
Also citing employer abuse is a Salvadoran couple fired from their Halifax hotel jobs when the woman got pregnant. They moved here to look for work in September.
In another case, 20 Filipinos arrived in Vancouver last May after each had paid a recruiter $5,000 plus airfare. But the factory where they were to work had burned down a month earlier. No one bothered to tell them, or to notify the government to cancel their work permits. At least two of them are now working illegally in Toronto.
(more…)