Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners
Nedra Pickler, Matt Apuzzo, Associated Press
February 20, 2009
WASHINGTON — The Obama administration, siding with the Bush White House, contended Friday that detainees in Afghanistan have no constitutional rights.
In a two-sentence court filing, the Justice Department said it agreed that detainees at Bagram Airfield cannot use U.S. courts to challenge their detention. The filing shocked human rights attorneys.
“The hope we all had in President Obama to lead us on a different path has not turned out as we’d hoped,” said Tina Monshipour Foster, a human rights attorney representing a detainee at the Bagram Airfield. “We all expected better.”
The Supreme Court last summer gave al-Qaida and Taliban suspects held at the U.S. naval base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, the right to challenge their detention. With about 600 detainees at Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan and thousands more held in Iraq, courts are grappling with whether they, too, can sue to be released.
Three months after the Supreme Court’s ruling on Guantanamo Bay, four Afghan citizens being detained at Bagram tried to challenge their detentions in U.S. District Court in Washington. Court filings alleged that the U.S. military had held them without charges, repeatedly interrogating them without any means to contact an attorney. Their petition was filed by relatives on their behalf since they had no way of getting access to the legal system.
The military has determined that all the detainees at Bagram are “enemy combatants.” The Bush administration said in a response to the petition last year that the enemy combatant status of the Bagram detainees is reviewed every six months, taking into consideration classified intelligence and testimony from those involved in their capture and interrogation.
After Barack Obama took office, a federal judge in Washington gave the new administration a month to decide whether it wanted to stand by Bush’s legal argument. Justice Department spokesman Dean Boyd says the filing speaks for itself.
“They’ve now embraced the Bush policy that you can create prisons outside the law,” said Jonathan Hafetz, an attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union who has represented several detainees.
The Justice Department argues that Bagram is different from Guantanamo Bay because it is in an overseas war zone and the prisoners there are being held as part of a military action. The government argues that releasing enemy combatants into the Afghan war zone, or even diverting U.S. personnel there to consider their legal cases, could threaten security.
The government also said if the Bagram detainees got access to the courts, it would allow all foreigners captured by the United States in conflicts worldwide to do the same.
It’s not the first time that the Obama administration has used a Bush administration legal argument after promising to review it. Last week, Attorney General Eric Holder announced a review of every court case in which the Bush administration invoked the state secrets privilege, a separate legal tool it used to have lawsuits thrown out rather than reveal secrets.
The same day, however, Justice Department attorney Douglas Letter cited that privilege in asking an appeals court to uphold dismissal of a suit accusing a Boeing Co. subsidiary of illegally helping the CIA fly suspected terrorists to allied foreign nations that tortured them.
Letter said that Obama officials approved his argument.
Source | See Also: Activists ’shocked’ at Clinton stance on China rights | Ignatieff on Obama visit: Crisis an opportunity for continental, global integration | After Obama praises torture ruling, civil liberties group appalled | Obama takes heat for third cabinet appointee that hasn’t paid taxes | Pass stimulus or watch out, Obama warns | Obama shuts network of CIA ‘ghost prisons’ | Obama requests Guantánamo Bay tribunals suspension | Inauguration triggers joy, jubilation around world | Obama calls for ‘dramatic action’ on stimulus package | CFR-Brookings to Dominate Obama Strategy | Obama appoints architects of economic collapse, financial globalism to economic team | Obama, like McCain, surrounds himself with elite CFR, Brookings powerbrokers | Sitting US Congressman: Expect shift towards world government under Obama | Change should be more than a slogan
February 23rd, 2009 at 5:00 pm
[...] Comments statism watch » Blog Archive » Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners on Obama shuts network of CIA ‘ghost prisons’statism watch » Blog [...]
February 24th, 2009 at 11:55 am
[...] | See Also under Torture: UK agents ‘colluded with torture in Pakistan’ | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | U.K. resident held at Gitmo alleges Canadian involvement in torture | Senior judges attack US [...]
March 4th, 2009 at 3:12 pm
[...] Drills Linked To Coming Economic Rage | Family furious after police raid East Vancouver home | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | Predator drones patrolling border irk Manitoba MLA | Schools seek more police as crime drops | [...]
March 27th, 2009 at 12:42 am
[...] Drills Linked To Coming Economic Rage | Family furious after police raid East Vancouver home | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | Predator drones patrolling border irk Manitoba MLA | Schools seek more police as crime drops | [...]
March 27th, 2009 at 3:04 am
[...] Drills Linked To Coming Economic Rage | Family furious after police raid East Vancouver home | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | Predator drones patrolling border irk Manitoba MLA | Schools seek more police as crime drops | [...]
April 2nd, 2009 at 7:08 am
[...] | Cost of Afghan mission jumps to $11.3-billion | Afghanistan victory unlikely, says DND manual | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | New Canadian commander in Afghanistan welcomes U.S. troop influx | Canadian troops could soon [...]
April 13th, 2009 at 5:38 am
[...] Pakistani officers helped plan Mumbai attacks, says India | Tortured Guantanamo detainee set free | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | Canadians tortured overseas sue government | ‘Bomb plot’ case jury dismissed | Report: CIA [...]
April 16th, 2009 at 2:47 pm
[...] Drills Linked To Coming Economic Rage | Family furious after police raid East Vancouver home | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | Predator drones patrolling border irk Manitoba MLA | Schools seek more police as crime drops | [...]
April 22nd, 2009 at 3:49 pm
[...] Drills Linked To Coming Economic Rage | Family furious after police raid East Vancouver home | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | Predator drones patrolling border irk Manitoba MLA | Schools seek more police as crime drops | [...]
May 10th, 2009 at 9:21 am
[...] | Cost of Afghan mission jumps to $11.3-billion | Afghanistan victory unlikely, says DND manual | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | New Canadian commander in Afghanistan welcomes U.S. troop influx | Canadian troops could soon [...]
May 14th, 2009 at 11:34 am
[...] perpetrators | Obama administration: Guantanamo detainees have ‘no constitutional rights’ | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | After Obama praises torture ruling, civil liberties group appalled | Obama shuts network of CIA [...]
May 28th, 2009 at 3:43 pm
[...] Pakistani officers helped plan Mumbai attacks, says India | Tortured Guantanamo detainee set free | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | Canadians tortured overseas sue government | ‘Bomb plot’ case jury dismissed | Report: CIA [...]
May 31st, 2009 at 8:17 am
[...] tapes | Tortured Guantanamo detainee set free | UK agents ‘colluded with torture in Pakistan’ | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | U.K. resident held at Gitmo alleges Canadian involvement in torture | Senior judges attack US [...]
October 9th, 2009 at 1:50 am
[...] [...]
November 26th, 2009 at 4:43 pm
[...] tapes | Tortured Guantanamo detainee set free | UK agents ‘colluded with torture in Pakistan’ | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | U.K. resident held at Gitmo alleges Canadian involvement in torture | Senior judges attack US [...]
December 19th, 2009 at 5:20 am
[...] rights’ | CIA destroyed 92 interview tapes | Tortured Guantanamo detainee set free | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | After Obama praises torture ruling, civil liberties group appalled | Obama shuts network of CIA [...]
December 21st, 2009 at 3:44 am
[...] tapes | Tortured Guantanamo detainee set free | UK agents ‘colluded with torture in Pakistan’ | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | U.K. resident held at Gitmo alleges Canadian involvement in torture | Senior judges attack US [...]
January 11th, 2010 at 1:47 pm
[...] tapes | Tortured Guantanamo detainee set free | UK agents ‘colluded with torture in Pakistan’ | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | U.K. resident held at Gitmo alleges Canadian involvement in torture | Senior judges attack US [...]
January 14th, 2010 at 3:21 pm
[...] tapes | Tortured Guantanamo detainee set free | UK agents ‘colluded with torture in Pakistan’ | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | U.K. resident held at Gitmo alleges Canadian involvement in torture | Senior judges attack US [...]
January 19th, 2010 at 5:28 pm
[...] rights’ | CIA destroyed 92 interview tapes | Tortured Guantanamo detainee set free | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | After Obama praises torture ruling, civil liberties group appalled | Obama shuts network of CIA [...]
February 4th, 2010 at 3:33 pm
[...]  overseas CIA ‘black sites’ to stay | Psychologists Helped Guide CIA Interrogations | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | After Obama praises torture ruling, civil liberties group appalled | Obama shuts network of CIA [...]
February 10th, 2010 at 5:05 pm
[...] | Tortured Guantanamo detainee set free | UK agents ‘colluded with torture in Pakistan’ | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | U.K. resident held at Gitmo alleges Canadian involvement in torture | Senior judges attack US [...]
February 13th, 2010 at 7:43 am
[...] | Tortured Guantanamo detainee set free | UK agents ‘colluded with torture in Pakistan’ | Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | U.K. resident held at Gitmo alleges Canadian involvement in torture | Senior judges attack US [...]
April 19th, 2010 at 6:19 pm
[...] Guantanamo detainees have ‘no constitutional rights’ | Tortured Guantanamo detainee set free| Obama backs Bush: No rights for Bagram prisoners | U.K. resident held at Gitmo alleges Canadian involvement in torture | Senior judges attack US [...]