statism watch

Water pact will deplete Great Lakes, expert fears

Share

New to the site? Visit the Memory Hole for a bit of context, to find out what we’re all about.

Linda Diebel, Toronto Star
July 22, 2008

A pact designed to preserve the Great Lakes is in reality a “slippery slope” that threatens severe harm to the world’s largest body of fresh water, a top U.S. environmental lawyer has warned Canadians.

“In effect, a precedent is being set, in that it allows for the commercialization of water. You are privatizing it,” James Olson said yesterday of an agreement among eight Great Lakes states now before the U.S. Congress and linked to Ontario and Quebec through a side deal.

Among other concerns, Olson criticizes an exemption in the Great Lakes Compact allowing water to be removed by private industry as long as it’s not “bulk diversion” — in other words, restricted to containers no more than 20 litres in Canada or 5.7 gallons in the U.S., with no limit on the number of containers a business, such as a bottler, can sell.

That means an important legal precedent has been set giving water a “product” exemption from the diversion ban on Great Lakes water at the heart of the deal. It is a product to be exploited for private gain, and not to be recognized as a public trust.

While Olson is worried about the gradual loss of water levels through the activities of, say, bottling companies, under current limitations, he predicts these quantitative restrictions will turn out to be mere formalities destined to be overturned in court challenges.

“This marks a significant step forward in safeguarding these waters on the U.S. side of the basin,” Michael Wilson, Canadian ambassador to the U.S., said July 11. “It is our hope that the U.S. Congress will move quickly in providing its consent to the compact.”

However, Meera Karunananthan, water resources analyst for the Council of Canadians, fears that the agreement further erodes the responsibility of the federal government to safeguard Canadian water.

“From a Canadian perspective, two agencies are mandated to protect our sovereignty over water,” she said, referring to the International Boundary Waters Treaty Act of 1909 and the International Joint Commission, the binational referee that regulates disputes.

“Those agencies are being gradually eroded, along with Canadian sovereignty,” she said.

Full Story | See Also under Water: Beware thirsty Americans, Kennedy tells Canada | Maybe Obama was right on NAFTA | Closed-door talks focusing on our water supply | Canada’s water needs protection from thirsty America: trade lawyer

Be Sociable, Share!

15 Responses to “Water pact will deplete Great Lakes, expert fears”

  1. MM - Now with blogosphere! Says:

    [...] Great Lakes, expert fears http://www.waterkeeper.ca/content/drink/water_pact_will_deplete_great.php http://statismwatch.ca/2008/07/22/water-pact-will-deplete-great-lakes-expert-fears/ [...]

  2. CoC media and blog coverage July 25 « council of canadians | london Says:

    [...] http://statismwatch.ca/2008/07/22/water-pact-will-deplete-great-lakes-expert-fears/ [...]

  3. statism watch » Blog Archive » Scientists Note Hormones in Water, Feminization of Fish Downstream of Montreal Says:

    [...] water, researchers suggest | Cut children’s fluoride exposure, report to Health Canada urges | Water pact will deplete Great Lakes, expert fears | Lakes across Canada face being turned into mine dump sites | Beware thirsty Americans, Kennedy [...]

  4. statism watch » Blog Archive » Scientists warn global warming accelerating Says:

    [...] sq km to be signed over to UNESCO | Population control thinktank to Britons: Have less children | Water pact will deplete Great Lakes, expert fears | Small Farmers Pushed to Plant GM Seed | Ontario joins continental WCI cap-and-trade scheme | [...]

  5. statism watch » Blog Archive » Changes to law could affect navigation of Canadian waters, critics say Says:

    [...] water, researchers suggest | Cut children’s fluoride exposure, report to Health Canada urges | Water pact will deplete Great Lakes, expert fears | Lakes across Canada face being turned into mine dump sites | Beware thirsty Americans, Kennedy [...]

  6. statism watch » Blog Archive » Canada’s bid for UN Security Council seat tied to water issue Says:

    [...] water, researchers suggest | Cut children’s fluoride exposure, report to Health Canada urges | Water pact will deplete Great Lakes, expert fears | Lakes across Canada face being turned into mine dump sites | Beware thirsty Americans, Kennedy [...]

  7. statism watch » Blog Archive » Ottawa to test taps for cancer contaminants Says:

    [...] water, researchers suggest | Cut children’s fluoride exposure, report to Health Canada urges | Water pact will deplete Great Lakes, expert fears | Lakes across Canada face being turned into mine dump sites | Beware thirsty Americans, Kennedy [...]

  8. statism watch » Blog Archive » U.N. ‘Climate Change’ Plan Would Likely Shift Trillions to Form New World Economy Says:

    [...] sq km to be signed over to UNESCO | Population control thinktank to Britons: Have less children | Water pact will deplete Great Lakes, expert fears | Small Farmers Pushed to Plant GM Seed | Ontario joins continental WCI cap-and-trade scheme | [...]

  9. statism watch » Blog Archive » Ontario unveils cap-and-trade legislation Says:

    [...] sq km to be signed over to UNESCO | Population control thinktank to Britons: Have less children | Water pact will deplete Great Lakes, expert fears | Small Farmers Pushed to Plant GM Seed | Ontario joins continental WCI cap-and-trade scheme | [...]

  10. statism watch » Blog Archive » IPCC Crushes Scientific Objectivity, 91-0 Says:

    [...] [...]

  11. statism watch » Blog Archive » Lord Nicholas Stern: The world’s future is being decided this weekend Says:

    [...] [...]

  12. statism watch » Blog Archive » Obama vows greenhouse gas emissions cuts Says:

    [...] [...]

  13. Marcus - ac repair (1 comments) Says:

    I think they are going down a slippery slope here. We need to maintain all our water ways.

  14. statism watch » Blog Archive » Canadian Gold giant faces Honduras inquiry into alleged heavy metal pollution Says:

    [...] water, researchers suggest | Cut children’s fluoride exposure, report to Health Canada urges | Water pact will deplete Great Lakes, expert fears | Lakes across Canada face being turned into mine dump sites | Beware thirsty Americans, Kennedy [...]

  15. statism watch » Blog Archive » Canada’s water policy needs overhaul: report Says:

    [...] | Bilderberg-connected Desmarais dynasty thinktank supports exporting Canada’s water | Water pact will deplete Great Lakes, expert fears | Beware thirsty Americans, Kennedy tells Canada | Closed-door talks focusing on our water supply | [...]